I was able to add SERVER5 back into the cluster. Unfortunately the server was autofailovered.
Here the log
Node ('ns_1@SERVER5') was automatically failovered.
[{last_heard,{1476,217471,476683}},
{stale_slow_status,{1476,217391,461051}},
{now,{1476,217461,477799}},
{active_buckets,["adw_dmp_helper","adw_dmp","adw_dmp_cache"]},
{ready_buckets,[]},
{status_latency,4050},
{outgoing_replications_safeness_level,
[{"adw_dmp_cache",green},{"adw_dmp_helper",green},{"adw_dmp",green}]},
{incoming_replications_conf_hashes,
[{"adw_dmp_cache",[]},
{"adw_dmp_helper",
[{'ns_1@SERVER1',51588383},
{'ns_1@SERVER2',31434318},
{'ns_1@SERVER3',5142064},
{'ns_1@SERVER4',47698658}]},
{"adw_dmp",
[{'ns_1@SERVER1',51588383},
{'ns_1@SERVER2',31434318},
{'ns_1@SERVER3',5142064},
{'ns_1@SERVER4',47698658}]}]},
{local_tasks,
[[{pid,<<"<0.32116.629>">>},
{bucket,<<"adw_dmp">>},
{original_target,{[{type,bucket}]}},
{progress,15},
{started_on,1476215735},
{total_vbuckets,408},
{trigger_type,scheduled},
{type,bucket_compaction},
{updated_on,1476217295},
{vbuckets_done,62}]]},
{memory,
[{total,543092384},
{processes,209005272},
{processes_used,208909576},
{system,334087112},
{atom,594537},
{atom_used,582551},
{binary,61681632},
{code,14338494},
{ets,244106688}]},
{system_memory_data,
[{system_total_memory,203143090176},
{free_swap,0},
{total_swap,0},
{cached_memory,76768473088},
{buffered_memory,45056},
{free_memory,5950480384},
{total_memory,203143090176}]},
{node_storage_conf,
[{db_path,"/opt/couchbase/var/lib/couchbase/data"},
{index_path,"/couchbase_indexes"}]},
{statistics,
[{wall_clock,{3367033655,5000}},
{context_switches,{683992261,0}},
{garbage_collection,{184362848,763910679225,0}},
{io,{{input,489634681301},{output,1442443299899}}},
{reductions,{152576132077,721049}},
{run_queue,0},
{runtime,{192841640,630}},
{run_queues,
{0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0}}]},
{system_stats,
[{cpu_utilization_rate,9.868007542426147},
{swap_total,0},
{swap_used,0},
{mem_total,203143090176},
{mem_free,82714206208}]},
{interesting_stats,
[{cmd_get,572.0},
{couch_docs_actual_disk_size,216535439645},
{couch_docs_data_size,156232156762},
{couch_spatial_data_size,0},
{couch_spatial_disk_size,0},
{couch_views_actual_disk_size,19698307868},
{couch_views_data_size,12829843192},
{curr_items,133287322},
{curr_items_tot,266242972},
{ep_bg_fetched,1.0},
{get_hits,399.0},
{mem_used,101170367517},
{ops,1552.0},
{vb_replica_curr_items,133129261}]},
{per_bucket_interesting_stats,
[{"adw_dmp",
[{cmd_get,317.0},
{couch_docs_actual_disk_size,210534646167},
{couch_docs_data_size,150718175657},
{couch_spatial_data_size,0},
{couch_spatial_disk_size,0},
{couch_views_actual_disk_size,19255124078},
{couch_views_data_size,12457328414},
{curr_items,129453593},
{curr_items_tot,258918489},
{ep_bg_fetched,1.0},
{get_hits,258.0},
{mem_used,92826191640},
{ops,669.0},
{vb_replica_curr_items,129464896}]},
{"adw_dmp_helper",
[{cmd_get,16.0},
{couch_docs_actual_disk_size,6000793478},
{couch_docs_data_size,5513981105},
{couch_spatial_data_size,0},
{couch_spatial_disk_size,0},
{couch_views_actual_disk_size,443183790},
{couch_views_data_size,372514778},
{curr_items,3660118},
{curr_items_tot,7324483},
{ep_bg_fetched,0.0},
{get_hits,2.0},
{mem_used,8299293448},
{ops,18.0},
{vb_replica_curr_items,3664365}]},
{"adw_dmp_cache",
[{cmd_get,239.0},
{couch_docs_data_size,0},
{curr_items,173611},
{curr_items_tot,0},
{ep_bg_fetched,0.0},
{get_hits,139.0},
{mem_used,44882429},
{ops,865.0},
{vb_replica_curr_items,0}]}]},
{processes_stats,
[{<<"godu/46123/ppid">>,46062},
{<<"godu/46123/mem_size">>,5971968},
{<<"godu/46123/mem_resident">>,1331200},
{<<"godu/46123/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"godu/46123/major_faults_raw">>,61},
{<<"cbq-engine/46399/ppid">>,46395},
{<<"cbq-engine/46399/mem_size">>,579633152},
{<<"cbq-engine/46399/mem_resident">>,7364608},
{<<"cbq-engine/46399/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"cbq-engine/46399/major_faults_raw">>,160},
{<<"indexer/46385/ppid">>,46383},
{<<"indexer/46385/mem_size">>,27131867136},
{<<"indexer/46385/mem_resident">>,1122639872},
{<<"indexer/46385/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"indexer/46385/major_faults_raw">>,148},
{<<"projector/46380/ppid">>,46378},
{<<"projector/46380/mem_size">>,580124672},
{<<"projector/46380/mem_resident">>,4452352},
{<<"projector/46380/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"projector/46380/major_faults_raw">>,89},
{<<"goxdcr/46136/ppid">>,46134},
{<<"goxdcr/46136/mem_size">>,363720704},
{<<"goxdcr/46136/mem_resident">>,4628480},
{<<"goxdcr/46136/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"goxdcr/46136/major_faults_raw">>,71},
{<<"sigar_port/46133/ppid">>,2469},
{<<"sigar_port/46133/mem_size">>,11972608},
{<<"sigar_port/46133/mem_resident">>,5087232},
{<<"sigar_port/46133/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"sigar_port/46133/major_faults_raw">>,0},
{<<"godu/46125/ppid">>,2469},
{<<"godu/46125/mem_size">>,4853760},
{<<"godu/46125/mem_resident">>,884736},
{<<"godu/46125/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"godu/46125/major_faults_raw">>,0},
{<<"beam.smp/46062/ppid">>,2469},
{<<"beam.smp/46062/mem_size">>,5799075840},
{<<"beam.smp/46062/mem_resident">>,1942224896},
{<<"beam.smp/46062/cpu_utilization">>,223},
{<<"beam.smp/46062/major_faults_raw">>,35},
{<<"memcached/81712/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"memcached/81712/mem_size">>,117734207488},
{<<"memcached/81712/mem_resident">>,113022160896},
{<<"memcached/81712/cpu_utilization">>,71},
{<<"memcached/81712/major_faults_raw">>,63},
{<<"saslauthd-port/80484/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"saslauthd-port/80484/mem_size">>,107495424},
{<<"saslauthd-port/80484/mem_resident">>,1802240},
{<<"saslauthd-port/80484/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"saslauthd-port/80484/major_faults_raw">>,23},
{<<"goport/46395/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"goport/46395/mem_size">>,5124096},
{<<"goport/46395/mem_resident">>,417792},
{<<"goport/46395/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"goport/46395/major_faults_raw">>,3},
{<<"goport/46383/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"goport/46383/mem_size">>,5124096},
{<<"goport/46383/mem_resident">>,425984},
{<<"goport/46383/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"goport/46383/major_faults_raw">>,0},
{<<"goport/46378/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"goport/46378/mem_size">>,5124096},
{<<"goport/46378/mem_resident">>,434176},
{<<"goport/46378/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"goport/46378/major_faults_raw">>,0},
{<<"goport/46134/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"goport/46134/mem_size">>,5124096},
{<<"goport/46134/mem_resident">>,434176},
{<<"goport/46134/cpu_utilization">>,0},
{<<"goport/46134/major_faults_raw">>,0},
{<<"beam.smp/2469/ppid">>,2379},
{<<"beam.smp/2469/mem_size">>,3318468608},
{<<"beam.smp/2469/mem_resident">>,796700672},
{<<"beam.smp/2469/cpu_utilization">>,14},
{<<"beam.smp/2469/major_faults_raw">>,20},
{<<"beam.smp/2379/ppid">>,1},
{<<"beam.smp/2379/mem_size">>,1593823232},
{<<"beam.smp/2379/mem_resident">>,45670400},
{<<"beam.smp/2379/cpu_utilization">>,1},
{<<"beam.smp/2379/major_faults_raw">>,1}]},
{index_status,[{num_connections,0}]},
{cluster_compatibility_version,262144},
{version,
[{lhttpc,"1.3.0"},
{os_mon,"2.2.14"},
{public_key,"0.21"},
{asn1,"2.0.4"},
{kernel,"2.16.4"},
{ale,"4.0.0-4051-community"},
{inets,"5.9.8"},
{ns_server,"4.0.0-4051-community"},
{crypto,"3.2"},
{ssl,"5.3.3"},
{sasl,"2.3.4"},
{stdlib,"1.19.4"}]},
{supported_compat_version,[4,0]},
{advertised_version,[4,0,0]},
{system_arch,"x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu"},
{wall_clock,3367033},
{memory_data,{203143090176,197231075328,{<19866.146.0>,41050832}}},
{disk_data,
[{"/dev",10240,0},
{"/run",39676388,11},
{"/",3904036336,6},
{"/dev/shm",99190960,0},
{"/run/lock",5120,0},
{"/sys/fs/cgroup",99190960,0},
{"/etc/machine-id",39676388,11},
{"/couchbase_indexes",937233624,3},
{"/boot",499656,8}]},
{meminfo,
<<"MemTotal: 198381924 kB\nMemFree: 5811140 kB\nMemAvailable: 78621668 kB\nBuffers: 44 kB\nCached: 74969204 kB\nSwapCached: 0 kB\nActive: 152109116 kB\nInactive: 37268700 kB\nActive(anon): 116936648 kB\nInactive(anon): 1525788 kB\nActive(file): 35172468 kB\nInactive(file): 35742912 kB\nUnevictable: 14344 kB\nMlocked: 14344 kB\nSwapTotal: 0 kB\nSwapFree: 0 kB\nDirty: 127316 kB\nWriteback: 49240 kB\nAnonPages: 114425100 kB\nMapped: 99992 kB\nShmem: 4048904 kB\nSlab: 2370436 kB\nSReclaimable: 2233008 kB\nSUnreclaim: 137428 kB\nKernelStack: 14784 kB\nPageTables: 263400 kB\nNFS_Unstable: 0 kB\nBounce: 0 kB\nWritebackTmp: 0 kB\nCommitLimit: 99190960 kB\nCommitted_AS: 149483864 kB\nVmallocTotal: 34359738367 kB\nVmallocUsed: 716036 kB\nVmallocChunk: 34258220536 kB\nHardwareCorrupted: 0 kB\nAnonHugePages: 0 kB\nHugePages_Total: 0\nHugePages_Free: 0\nHugePages_Rsvd: 0\nHugePages_Surp: 0\nHugepagesize: 2048 kB\nDirectMap4k: 119548 kB\nDirectMap2M: 3979264 kB\nDirectMap1G: 199229440 kB\n">>}]